Agency Comparison · Sources checked November 10, 2026
Broughton Partners Alternative: Co-Counsel Retainers or Your Own Cases
Broughton Partners is a Savannah, Georgia case acquisition company that advertises for mass tort claimants, screens them in its own intake center, and delivers signed retainers to law firms through an originating-firm co-counsel structure. Firms looking for a Broughton Partners alternative are usually deciding whether they want that structure or a direct marketing engagement. This page sets out what Broughton publishes about its model and where ours differs.
Quick answer
Broughton Partners suits firms that want to enter mass torts without building a practice: it delivers signed retainers at a set price, the firm co-counsels with Broughton's originating firm, The Goldwater Law Firm, and a litigating firm handles the case on preset fee splits. It also offers a group-buy program and campaign financing. It publishes no prices, fee-split percentages, or replacement terms. Mass Tort Marketing Agency is the alternative for firms that want the claimant to sign with them directly, with no originating firm on the retainer, every lead exclusive, and ad accounts the firm owns.

Who Broughton Partners is, from its own materials
Broughton Partners is based at 110 Park of Commerce Drive in Savannah, Georgia. It describes itself as a technology-first law firm marketing and case acquisition company. Cason Carter is CEO, Jason Crystal COO, and Sid Toama CMO, and LinkedIn lists the company at 51 to 200 employees.
Its process has four published steps: advertise, screen claimants in an in-house intake center, deliver an intake packet (signed retainer, HIPAA and HITECH authorization, and completed intake), and connect the cases with litigating firms. Its marketing page states that Broughton runs ads for The Goldwater Law Firm, which serves as the originating firm for all its campaigns, and that claimants sign with Goldwater and the client firm as co-counsel.
Around that core it offers a Partner Portal for case visibility, a Consortium for Mass Tort Access that pools firms to enter torts at a lower cost, and BP Finance, a non-recourse loan for campaign spend. It lists thirteen active litigations, including GLP-1 and Ozempic, rideshare assault, Bard port catheter, Roblox, hernia mesh, Roundup, hair relaxer, and social media addiction.
| Detail | What is published | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Broughton Partners, 110 Park of Commerce Dr., Suite 200, Savannah, Georgia; "technology first law firm marketing and case acquisition company" | broughtonpartners.com/about-us |
| Leadership | Cason Carter, CEO; Jason Crystal, COO; Sid Toama, CMO | broughtonpartners.com/meet-the-team |
| Co-counsel structure | "Broughton Partners runs ads for The Goldwater Law Firm." Claimants are signed with Goldwater Law Firm and the client firm as counsel: "Your firm and Goldwater Law Firm Co-counsel." | broughtonpartners.com/marketing |
| Originating firm | The Goldwater Law Firm "is integrated throughout our process." Broughton cites a lawyer's responsibility for non-lawyer assistants as the reason for the model | broughtonpartners.com/originating-firm |
| Pricing unit | "Our set price per verified signed retainer model provides transparency." No amounts are published. The CEO has said pricing depends on the risk and demand for each tort | broughtonpartners.com blog post |
| Litigating firms | "We connect your cases with the top Litigators." Certified litigation partners must contact claimants within 48 hours of delivery and be able to take defendants to trial. The CEO has said litigating firms work on preset fee splits | broughtonpartners.com/certified-litigators |
| Intake | "Our in-house legal intake center" with duplicate-claim checks, identity verification through TransUnion, nurse consultants, and case audits before delivery. Hours are given as "24/7" on the homepage and "363 days a year" on the About page | broughtonpartners.com/intake |
| Compliance | States it has earned CompliancePoint's iComply TCPA Compliance Seal through independent audits, stores web consent with TrustedForm, and records verbal consent on phone intake | broughtonpartners.com/process-diligence |
| Channels | Paid social (Meta, LinkedIn, TikTok), paid search on Google and Bing, YouTube video, SEO, and email | broughtonpartners.com/marketing |
| Group buy | Consortium for Mass Tort Access: "collective buying power of the group to access mass tort opportunities at a lower entry point" | broughtonpartners.com consortium page |
| Financing | BP Finance: a non-recourse loan of up to twice the firm's own contribution, secured by the campaign's cases. "The funder is repaid 2x-3x the loaned amount dependent on settlement timing." | broughtonpartners.com financing post |
| Active litigations | Thirteen listed, including GLP-1/Ozempic, rideshare assault, Bard implanted port catheter, Roblox, hernia mesh, video game addiction, Paraquat, Roundup, hair relaxer, and social media addiction | broughtonpartners.com/active-litigations |
What we could not find published
- Any dollar price per retainer, for any tort, or the payment amounts for the consortium program.
- The fee-split percentages among the client firm, the originating firm, and the litigating firm.
- Replacement criteria, the replacement window, or refund terms. The portal lets firms request replacements; the rules are not published.
- Any guarantee, or a measured fall-off or stick rate.
- Whether a retainer is exclusive to one client firm, and what happens to leads that do not qualify.
- Spanish-language or bilingual intake, and where intake agents are located.
- The names of its consumer-facing advertising brands and of its certified litigating firms.
- Whether affiliates or third-party lead sources are used.
- Who funds BP Finance loans.
Disclosure: this page is published by Mass Tort Marketing Agency, a competitor of Broughton Partners, and we have an obvious commercial interest in your decision. Everything stated about Broughton Partners comes from the public sources linked above, checked on November 10, 2026. It describes public positioning, not internal practices, and nothing here is a claim about Broughton Partners’s lead quality or client results. “Not published” means we did not find the detail, not that the capability is absent. Offers change, so confirm current terms with Broughton Partners directly.
The deciding question
Whose name is on the retainer, and how is the fee divided?
Broughton's model is built for firms that want mass tort exposure without running a mass tort practice. The firm pays a set price per signed retainer, is named on the retainer as co-counsel with The Goldwater Law Firm, and a litigating firm works the case on preset splits. The firm does not need its own intake floor, its own advertising, or trial capacity in that tort. For a personal injury firm diversifying into dockets it will never litigate, that is a coherent package, and the financing and group-buy options lower the entry cost further.
The trade is in the structure of the case. The claimant responded to advertising run for the originating firm, the retainer names more than one firm, and the fee is divided among the client firm, the originating firm, and the litigating firm. Broughton does not publish those percentages, so the firm's return depends on numbers it must get in writing. Co-counsel fee division is also governed by each state's version of Rule 1.5(e), which generally requires client consent and, in many states, joint responsibility.
A marketing engagement is a different thing. The firm pays for advertising and intake, the claimant signs with that firm alone, and no other firm takes a share unless the firm chooses to refer or associate counsel later on its own terms. That keeps more of the fee and all of the client relationship, and it means the firm needs a plan to litigate or refer each case itself. Which is better depends on whether you want to own the docket or own a share of it.
Broughton Partners and Mass Tort Marketing Agency, side by side
The Broughton Partners column restates only what its public materials say. The right-hand column describes our own model.
| Category | Broughton Partners | Mass Tort Marketing Agency |
|---|---|---|
| Core business | Case acquisition: advertising, in-house intake, signed retainers, and placement with litigating firms | Mass tort and personal injury plaintiff acquisition only: advertising and intake, ending at the signed retainer |
| Who is on the retainer | The Goldwater Law Firm, as originating firm, and the client firm as co-counsel; a litigating firm then handles the case | The client firm only. We are a marketing agency, not a law firm, and take no position on the retainer or the fee |
| Pricing | Set price per verified signed retainer, varying by tort; amounts not published | MVA programs from $10,000/month; mass tort from $25,000/month per tort, priced and reported on cost per signed retainer |
| Fee division | Divided among client firm, originating firm, and litigating firm on preset splits; percentages not published | None. The firm keeps its full fee unless it chooses to associate or refer |
| Litigating the case | Arranged through its certified litigation partners | The firm litigates or refers on its own terms; we do not place cases |
| Intake | In-house intake center with identity checks, nurse consultants, and case audits; bilingual intake not mentioned | 24/7 bilingual intake run in-house, screening against the case criteria for each active tort |
| Exclusivity | No exclusivity statement on its site; group-buy members share retainers by design | Every lead delivered exclusively to one firm, contractually named, never resold or syndicated |
| Consent records | TrustedForm for web consent, recorded verbal consent, and a stated third-party TCPA compliance seal | Documented consent captured on every lead with TrustedForm or Jornaya certificates, delivered with the lead |
| Financing and entry cost | BP Finance non-recourse loans and a consortium group buy | No financing product. The firm funds its own campaign |
When Broughton Partners is the better fit
- You want mass tort exposure but do not intend to litigate those cases yourself.
- You would rather pay a set price per signed retainer than fund and monitor an advertising campaign.
- You want a lower entry point through a group buy, or want to finance the spend against the cases.
- You are comfortable being co-counsel alongside an originating firm and sharing the fee on preset splits.
When Mass Tort Marketing Agency is the better fit
- You want the claimant to sign with your firm alone and to keep the full fee.
- You already litigate mass torts, or have referral relationships you prefer to choose yourself.
- You want each lead named as exclusive to your firm in the contract.
- You want intake in English and Spanish, and campaigns in ad accounts you own.
See how it works: mass tort lead generation, intake and screening, exclusive leads, and pricing.
Questions to ask Broughton Partners, and us, before you sign
- What is the price per signed retainer for this tort today, and is it fixed for my whole order?
- What are the fee-split percentages among my firm, the originating firm, and the litigating firm?
- Who are the litigating firms, and do I choose which one handles my cases?
- Is each retainer delivered to my firm only, or can other client firms be on it?
- What are the replacement rules: what qualifies, within how many days, and is there a cap?
- What share of delivered retainers have historically dropped out before filing?
- Does my state's rule on fee division require anything of me that this structure does not already cover?
- If I use BP Finance, who is the lender and what is the total repayment under each settlement timeline?
Broughton Partners alternatives, answered
- What is the best alternative to Broughton Partners?
- It depends on which part of the model you want to change. If you want signed claimants at a set price without the co-counsel structure, compare Adwire Media and Tort Experts. If you want a marketing engagement where the claimant signs with your firm alone and every lead is exclusive, Mass Tort Marketing Agency is the alternative. If you want television-led acquisition, look at Whitehardt, CAMG, or CASE Legal Media.
- How does Broughton Partners' co-counsel model work?
- According to its marketing page, Broughton Partners runs advertising for The Goldwater Law Firm, which serves as the originating firm for all its campaigns. Claimants sign with Goldwater and the client firm as co-counsel. Broughton then connects the cases with litigating firms. Its CEO has described the litigating firm as working on preset fee splits; the percentages are not published.
- How much does Broughton Partners charge per retainer?
- Broughton Partners does not publish prices. One of its blog posts describes a set price per verified signed retainer, and its CEO has said pricing depends on the risk and demand for each tort, with earlier-stage torts costing less. Ask for the price for your tort, and whether it holds for your full order.
- Is buying retainers from Broughton Partners the same as hiring a marketing agency?
- No. With a marketing agency, the firm pays for advertising and intake and the claimant signs with that firm alone. In Broughton's published model, the firm is co-counsel with an originating law firm and the fee is divided among the firms involved. That changes the economics and brings in your state's rules on dividing fees between firms, so review the structure with ethics counsel.
- Are Broughton Partners' retainers exclusive?
- Its site makes no statement on exclusivity either way. Each claimant signs with the originating firm and the client firm, and in its Consortium for Mass Tort Access several member firms participate together. Confirm in writing whether a retainer you buy outside the consortium names your firm as the only client firm.
- What are BP Finance and the Consortium for Mass Tort Access?
- BP Finance is campaign funding: Broughton describes a non-recourse loan of up to twice the firm's own contribution, secured by the campaign's cases, with the funder repaid two to three times the loaned amount depending on settlement timing. The Consortium for Mass Tort Access pools firms so they can enter a tort at a lower cost than buying alone.
- Does Mass Tort Marketing Agency co-counsel or take a share of fees?
- No. Mass Tort Marketing Agency is a marketing agency, not a law firm. It is paid for advertising and intake, the claimant signs with the client firm alone, and it takes no share of any legal fee. Firms that want help placing cases with litigating counsel will need to arrange that themselves.
Keep comparing: all ten alternatives side by side, the 2026 ranking of mass tort marketing firms, or the 10-point agency selection guide.
Keep going
Related reading
Tort Experts alternative
Lead-vendor economics versus a managed acquisition programme, with the trade-offs stated.
Whitehardt alternative
TV-heavy agency models compared against multi-channel plaintiff acquisition.
CAMG alternative
Broadcast-first versus digital-first mass tort acquisition, compared on cost per retainer.
How to choose a mass tort marketing agency
The questions, references, and reporting standards that separate real acquisition partners from lead resellers.
Rankings.io alternative
SEO-led versus acquisition-led growth, and which fits a firm buying mass tort volume.
Ready to review your next mass tort campaign?
Tell us about your firm, target cases, and intake capacity. A strategist will respond in under 5 minutes during business hours with practical next steps.
Speed-to-lead is the largest single lever in intake conversion: the gap between a 5-minute and a 30-minute callback is measured in retainers lost, not opportunities lost. The same clock is running on the torts you have not claimed yet.
Built for personal injury firms, intake teams, and mass tort dockets
